Montauk Blue Hotel

Two-night stay with my husband for his bday. The balcony of our room had an impressive view of the ocean once we were moved to a different room. And the beach staff members were very friendly. Janet and the racial minority front desk agents were nice and welcoming. The location is pretty convenient. The blond, heavy set lady from the front desk was condescending and can’t be bothered to help. Upon checkout, she acted like I was invisible, though she was friendly and attentive to white folks. The bed was the most uncomfortable bed we’ve ever had — and we travel all over the world, spending more than 100 nights annually at hotels. No amenities, like a restaurant, bar, or any kind of food service. No elevator that can take you to the 2nd floor, which may be an issue for those with disabilities. The water pressure in the shower is very weak. The room itself was very small and outdated, with a carpet that needed to be changed a few years ago. The carpet in the balcony is quite disgusting and housekeeping didn’t vacuum it during our stay. The indoor pool is far away from the ocean. No gym of any kind. The WiFi didn’t work at all during our stay, which was supposed to be included with the $35/day resort fee.

My wife and I were very impressed with the hotel, staff, pool and the view. The only reason for my 4-star rating was that the bed was not as comfortable as it should be. The hotel is right on the beach. We had a room on the ground floor, so we could walk right on the beach. There has been a significant about of dune work- so access to the beach was a few steps away. Montauk is very quiet off-season- and we enjoyed coming back for a visit.

Nice hotel but dated. Our room was on the ground floor near the pool and beach entrance. (and by the staircase) The rooms in itself were nice and clean. A/C worked but noisy but we left the screen door open great breeze. Great view of the beach, nice little patio to sit and relax. Our room had a bathtub our sons room next door didn’t. The staff couldn’t be more helpful and nicer. I would not stay in that same room location would stay further away towards the office. Extremely noisy by the stairs as the buildings are old. They give you towels, chairs and umbrella and set it up. The pool is great and especially the jacuzzi.We would only go after Labor Day too expensive.

I spent the night at this hotel and it was great. The room was large, comfortable bed super clean ! There’s a balcony ( I was on 2nd floor ) and you sit out looking over the ocean. The staff could not be more pleasant and helpful. Great location, beachfront & chairs, umbrella & towels are all brought out to you on the beach. There is an indoor pool which looked nice and clean although I didn’t use it. Location to town is excellent you can walk to shops, the bakery and breakfast spots easily All in all great place Highly recommended

We had a fantastic time at the Montauk Blue Hotel. Our ocean front room was clean and comfortable, great deck, and the beach was beautiful. Loved the friendly service with beach chairs and umbrella. We are definitely looking forward to coming back!

Very clean. Enjoyed having 2 chairs in shaded back porch facing ocean and 2 lounge chairs uncovered in the sun. Great beach service with umbrella, nice chairs and towels provided and set up for you. Very close to main street so easy walk to restaurants and shops. Only negative was the bed was too soft for us. Would visit again.

This is the absolute best choice of lodging in all of Montauk. The location is right on the ocean and the staff is amazing. They provide beaches, umbrellas, and towels. The Jacuzzi and pool are awesome. And the place is kept clean, above and beyond expectations, on a daily basis.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Five stars! Keep in mind this is a renovated old motel in Montauk. I think a 3 star overall property based on google. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️location . Right ON the Atlantic Ocean. Most rooms overlooking the beach. Make sure you book ‘oceanfront’ if you want a direct view . Right in town. Very walkable to all restaurants and shops. Keep in mind if you have health and or mobility issues and choose lower level rooms . The stairs in the heat can be a beast. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️chairs,umbrellas , towels provided and set up for you included in the ‘resort fee’. ⭐️⭐️⭐️indoor pool. Sort of covered in clear glass/ plexiglass. Attendant, towels, restrooms, picnic and lounge chairs inside and out. It’s an average but clean pool. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️rooms. Very clean, modern decor, bathroom well laid out and great function. Plenty of counter space. Beds comfortable, private balcony, dining table for two in room, pull out couch, tv, microwave, small fridge, coffee maker with coffee. ☀️no restaurant on premises but many local eateries within walking distance. Parking is free and you’re given one pass for one car.

l hesitate to write this, in fear that the secret escape that the Montauk Blue will be let put, but last week was I believe our fifth annual (aside from 2020) Montauk vacation. each time we've stayed at the Blue and each time it exceeds expectations. It may look from the outside like a "motel" but it is far from it. we are recognized at check in each year, and our beach needs don't even need to be repeated each day - management anf staff takes the time to remember you day after day, year after year. (shout out to javier!) there's not a bad room on the property. most are ocean facing and you habe your own balcony. somehow housekeeping keeps your room spotless each day despite the inevitable copious amount of sand dragged in daily. check in is at 3 - but arrive any time that day and you are given beach and pool access until your room is ready. you are minutes walking to delis, pancakes, pizza even the 7/11 (they carry the best firewood for your beach campfire) Of note: chair and umbrella service is 10-5 so if you plan on sitting on the beach outside of these hours, pack beach chairs. Cried when I left and counting the seconds until next summer.